Quantum computers: Trust is good, proof is better

Workgroup Walther Group

30. Sep 2013  — A quantum computer can solve tasks not tractable with conventional supercomputers. The question of how one can, nevertheless, verify the reliability of a quantum computer was recently answered in an experiment at the University of Vienna. The conclusions are published in the reputed scientific journal Nature Physics.

Quantum computers: Trust is good, proof is better

The image is an illustration of the fundamental question: can quantum computations be verified by entities that are inherently unable to compute the results themselves? (Copyright: EQUINOX GRAPHICS)

The harnessing of quantum phenomena, such as superposition and entanglement, holds great promise for constructing future supercomputers. One huge advantage of such quantum computers is that they are capable of performing a variety of tasks much quicker than their conventional counterparts. The use of quantum computers for these purposes raises a significant challenge: how can one verify the results provided by such a computer?

It is only recently that theoretical developments have provided methods to test a quantum computer without having an additional quantum computer at hand. The international research team around Philip Walther at the University of Vienna have now demonstrated a new protocol, where the quantum computational results can be verified without using additional quantum computer resources.

Laying traps for a quantum computer

In order to test the quantum computer the scientists inserted “traps” into the tasks. The traps are short intermediate calculations to which the user knows the result in advance. In the case that the quantum computer does not do its job properly the trap delivers a result that differs from the expected one. “In this way, the user can verify how reliable the quantum computer really is”, explains Stefanie Barz (Vienna), first author of the study. The more traps the user builds into the tasks the more sure the user can be that the quantum computer indeed computes accurately.

“We designed the test in such a way that the quantum computer cannot distinguish the trap from its normal tasks” say Elham Kashefi (Edinburgh) and Joseph Fitzsimons (Singapore), theorists and co-authors of the paper. This is an important requirement to guarantee that the quantum computer is not able to tweak the test result. The researchers have also tested whether the quantum computer really resorts to quantum resources. Thereby, they can sure that even a maliciously constructed quantum computer cannot fool them into accepting incorrect results.

Implementing the idea with photons

For this first demonstration the researchers used an optical quantum computer, where single light particles, so-called photons, carried the information. The demonstrated protocol is generic, but optical quantum computers seem to be ideally suited for this task. The mobility of photons allows for easy interactions with the quantum computer. Philip Walther is optimistic about the prospects raised by this experiment which shows promising control mechanisms for future quantum computers. And, moreover, that it might lead to new tools for probing even complex quantum resources.

International Research Collaboration

The project is an international cooperation of researchers from the University of Vienna, the Centre for Quantum Technologies at the National University of Singapore and the Singapore University of Technology and Design as well as the University of Edinburgh. The research has been partly funded by the European Commission (Q-ESSENCE and QUILMI), the Austrian Science Fund (SFB-FoQuS, START Y585-N20), the ERA-Net CHISTERA project (QUASAR), the Vienna Science and Technology Fund (ICT12-041), the Air Force Office of Scientific Research (FA8655-11-1), and from the Singapore National Research Foundation (NRF-NRFF2013-01) and the Ministry of Education as well as the UK Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EP/E059600/1).



Experimental verification of quantum computation: Stefanie Barz, Joseph F. Fitzsimons, Elham Kashefi, Philip Walther. Nature Physics, September 2013
Doi: 10.1038/nphys2763

Scientific Contact
Dr. Stefanie Barz
Quantum optics, quantum nanophysics and quantum information
Faculty of Physics, University of Vienna

Boltzmanngasse 5
1090 Vienna,

T +43-1-4277-72567